What is the Difference Between Mutual Funds and Shares?
When it comes to investing in the financial market, people are often left confused between the two popular options: mutual funds vs shares. While both offer opportunities for wealth creation across various time horizons, they differ significantly in their structure, risk profile, and investment approach. Let us explore the fundamental differences between mutual funds and shares, so that you can make well-informed decisions that align with your financial goals.
Mutual Funds: An Overview
Mutual funds collect money from multiple investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of securities, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, and/or other securities. When you invest in a mutual fund, you are essentially buying units or shares of the fund, and your money is combined with that of other investors to create a large pool of assets.
These funds are managed by professional fund managers who have expertise in financial markets and investment analysis. Fund managers make decisions on behalf of the investors, selecting and managing the securities within the fund's portfolio with the goal to achieve the stated investment objectives.
Mutual funds come in various types, catering to different investment goals and risk tolerances. Equity funds invest predominantly in stocks, while debt funds focus on fixed-income securities. There are also balanced funds that hold a mix of both stocks and bonds, and specialty funds that focus on specific sectors or themes. Before investing in a mutual fund, you should carefully review the fund's objectives, risk factors, fees, and historical performance. Each fund has its unique investment strategy, and it's essential to choose one that aligns with your financial goals and risk appetite.
Shares: An Overview
Shares,on the other hand, give you part ownership of a specific company. When you purchase equity shares (also known as stocks or equities) of a company, you become a shareholder with a proportionate ownership stake in the company. This ownership is typically represented by shares in the company's stock. As a shareholder, you may also have certain rights, such as voting in annual general meetings and influencing certain company decisions.
Shares are traded on various stock exchanges such as the BSE and the NSE. These exchanges serves as a platform for investors to buy and sell shares, with prices determined by the dynamics of supply and demand. It is worth noting that investing in shares requires diligent research and analysis of the company's fundamentals, financial performance, industry outlook, and competitive positioning.
Shares offer investors the opportunity to participate directly in the growth and success of individual companies. However, they also carry individual company-specific risks, making diversification an essential consideration to mitigate potential losses.
Mutual Funds vs Shares: Key Differences
Here is a table that summarises the key differences between mutual funds and shares across a variety of parameters:
Factor of Comparison | Mutual Funds | Shares |
|---|---|---|
| Investment Structure | Pooled investment in diversified portfolio of securities (stocks, bonds, money market instruments) | Individual ownership in a specific company (represents ownership shares) |
| Professional Management | Managed by professional fund managers | No professional management, self managed by the investor |
| Diversification | Offers inherent diversification benefits, spreading risk | Reliant on individual listed company's performance |
| Voting Rights | Limited to voting on specific matters, only in certain cases | Full voting rights as a shareholder |
| Liquidity | Generally high liquidity; can redeem units at Net Asset Value (NAV) | Liquidity varies depending on the demand for the specific company's shares |
| Regulation and Transparency | Subject to strict regulatory oversight and transparency (SEBI governed) | Companies may have varying levels of disclosure and transparency |
| Investment Flexibility | Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) and Systematic Withdrawal Plans (SWPs) available | Customisable portfolio based on individual preferences and risk tolerance |
| Potential for High Returns | Returns are dependent on overall performance of the fund's underlying securities | Potential for higher returns if invested in well-performing companies |
Advantages of Mutual Funds Over Shares
Mutual funds and shares have distinct advantages and cater to different investor preferences. Let’s explore why some investors may prefer mutual funds over shares:
Diversification
Mutual funds offer inherent diversification benefits. By investing in a mutual fund, you gain exposure to a wide range of securities, reducing the impact of a single company's performance on your investment. This diversification helps spread risk and can potentially provide a more stable return profile.
Professional Management
Mutual funds are managed by professional fund managers who have expertise in analysing and selecting investments. Their in-depth knowledge of the financial markets allows them to make informed decisions on behalf of the investors, saving you time and effort.
Accessibility And Affordability
Mutual funds often have lower entry barriers compared to individual shares. With a modest investment, you can gain access to a diversified portfolio managed by experts, which may not be feasible when purchasing individual shares.
Liquidity
Mutual funds generally offer high liquidity, allowing you to redeem your investment and access your funds quickly. This feature can be beneficial, especially during unforeseen financial needs.
Regulation And Transparency
Mutual funds are subject to strict regulatory oversight, providing investors with transparency and confidence in the investment process. Fund managers are required to disclose their holdings regularly, enabling investors to track their investments' performance.
Systematic Investment And Withdrawal Plans
Mutual funds offer the convenience of systematic investment plans (SIPs) and systematic withdrawal plans (SWPs). SIPs allow you to invest a fixed amount regularly, promoting disciplined investing. SWPs, on the other hand, facilitate periodic withdrawals to meet your financial requirements.
Advantages of Shares Over Mutual Funds
While mutual funds have their advantages, it's prudent to consider the benefits of investing in individual shares as well:
Direct Ownership And Control
When you invest in shares of a company, you have direct ownership and voting rights, allowing you to influence the company's decisions and policies.
Potential For High Returns
While individual shares can be riskier due to lack of diversification, they also offer the potential for higher returns, especially if you invest in well-performing companies.
Dividends And Capital Gains
Shareholders may receive dividends when the company distributes its profits to shareholders. Additionally, you can benefit from capital gains if the share price appreciates over time.
Investment Flexibility
Investing in individual shares allows you to build a customised portfolio based on your risk tolerance, investment horizon, and personal preferences.
Mutual Funds vs Share Market: What’s Right For You?
In conclusion, the difference between mutual funds and share market investments lies in their investment strategy, approach, and risk profiles, among other factors. Mutual funds offer diversification, professional management, accessibility, and liquidity, making them an attractive choice for many investors. On the other hand, shares provide direct ownership, the potential for high returns, and investment flexibility.
Mutual Funds vs Stock Investments – the decision depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment preferences. Some investors may prefer the ease and diversification of mutual funds, while others may opt for individual shares to exercise direct control over their investments.
Ultimately, a well-balanced investment strategy may include a mix of both mutual funds and individual shares to optimise risk and reward. Irrespective of the path you choose, it's crucial to conduct thorough research, seek professional advice, and align your investments with your eventual financial objectives. By understanding the nuances of, and differences between, mutual funds and shares, you can navigate the financial markets with confidence and potentially build a robust investment portfolio.
More Related Articles
What is NAV and How is NAV Calculated
29 July 2024 | 5 mins read
NAV is the acronym for Net Asset Value, and it represents the net value of an entity. In the case of mutual funds, NAV means the market value per unit of the fund. NAV of a mutual fund scheme is derived basis the difference between total assets and total liabilities divided by the total number of outstanding units. A mutual fund NAV represents the per share or unit price of a mutual fund scheme on a specific date or time. Usually, the NAV of a new mutual fund (NFO) scheme begins at Rs. 10 and gradually increases as the assets under management grows. All mutual fund schemes including open-ended, closed-ended, and interval schemes across equity, debt and hybrid categories have NAVs which are driven by market movements.
What is SIP & it’s benefits
29 July 2024 | 13 mins read
Retail investors often shy away from the world of investing because they believe that you need a lot of money to start investing in the stock market. And while that may be the case for stocks like MRF Ltd. where you need Rs. 87,880 (as of 29th December 2022) to buy one share, investors often forget that there is a way for them to invest in expensive stocks with just Rs 500. We are referring to Systematic Investment Plans or SIP offered by mutual funds. Popularised by the slogan, ‘mutual funds sahi hai’, India has seen a phenomenal growth in the number of registered SIPs. In fact, as per the Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI), the total number of mutual fund SIP accounts in India stood at 6.05 crore with a cumulative value of Rs. 13,306 crore as of November 2022. And while the concept of SIP is fairly straightforward, investors often fail to understand how SIP works and the different types of SIPs they can register. But don’t worry as in this article we will decode everything about systematic investment plans.
What is Large Cap Fund
29 July 2024 | 4 mins read
Capital markets have long been considered an excellent avenue for creating wealth. And one of the most popular investment instruments is equity shares. Investors can buy equity stocks directly from the market. But this can be risky due to lack of diversification and active management. So, as an alternative, investors choose mutual funds that invest in a basket of equity stocks. This results in diversification and active asset management. Equity mutual funds are bifurcated into three categories based on the market capitalisation of the underlying companies, namely large cap funds, mid cap funds, and small cap funds. Of these, large cap funds are extremely popular among conservative long-term investors, retirees and even stock market beginners with low-risk appetite.
FAQ
What is the primary difference between mutual funds and shares?
The main difference lies in their investment structure. Mutual funds pool money from multiple investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of securities, offering inherent diversification. On the other hand, shares represent individual ownership in a specific company, giving shareholders direct control and potential voting rights.
In mutual funds vs shares, which investment option provides better diversification?
Mutual funds offer better diversification since they invest in a wide range of securities, spreading risk across various assets. In contrast, investing in individual shares exposes you to the performance of a single company, making it less diversified.
Are mutual funds managed by professionals?
Yes, mutual funds are professionally managed by experienced fund managers. These experts analyse the financial markets and select investments based on the fund's objectives. Their expertise adds value to the fund and saves investors from the need to make individual investment decisions.
Do shareholders in a company have voting rights?
Yes, shareholders in a company have voting rights that allow them to participate in certain company decisions. The extent of voting rights may vary depending on the type of shares held and the company's policies.
Can I access my money quickly if I invest in mutual funds or shares?
Mutual funds generally offer high liquidity, allowing investors to redeem their units and access their funds at the fund's Net Asset Value (NAV). For shares, liquidity varies depending on the demand for the specific company's shares in the market.
How do I choose between mutual funds and shares for my investment portfolio?
Your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment preferences are the key considerations while choosing between mutual funds and shares. If you seek diversification, professional management, and ease of access, mutual funds may be a suitable choice. On the other hand, if you prefer direct ownership, potential for higher returns, and customised portfolios, individual shares might be more appealing.